Main Street Creamery Menu (Updated 2026)

Welcome to Main Street Creamery, a delightful ice cream haven located in the heart of Sarasota, Florida. With a charming atmosphere and a menu packed with irresistible flavors, this creamery offers something for every sweet tooth. Signature offerings include the indulgent Triple Peanut Butter and the refreshing Key Lime Pie ice creams, both priced at a reasonable US$8.00 per pint. For those craving a classic treat, you can't go wrong with the Cookies N Cream half-gallon for just US$16.00.

Local patrons rave about the creamy texture, with many noting that it contains 20% more cream for an extra luxurious experience. The friendly staff and inviting atmosphere enhance the overall experience, ensuring you feel right at home. Whether you're enjoying a scoop or a shake, Main Street Creamery delivers deliciousness that keeps customers returning for more.

The menu emphasizes classic and innovative ice cream options, with Cookie Dough, Siesta Ice Cream, and Gelato as key highlights. Pricing indicates that pint-sized servings are consistently priced at US$8.00, while half-gallon options are double that at US$16.00, suggesting a straightforward value scaling. Bottled drinks are offered at a lower price point, ranging from US$3.00 to US$5.00, providing budget-friendly beverage choices alongside premium ice cream items. The presence of nostalgic soda flavors complements the dessert-focused menu, suitable for casual daytime or early evening visits.